Fostering Innovative Growth in Regions Exposed to Low Carbon Transition

Valerie J. Karplus, Michael Kearney, and Sohum Pawar

September 2020

Sources of innovative growth have the potential to mitigate the localized adverse impacts of a low-carbon energy transition. Transitions themselves may contribute new activities related to clean energy. To explore this potential, we examine the relationship between transition exposure and regional innovation in the United States. We find that innovative activity is generally weak in areas exposed to transition, especially in those places with high shares of fossil fuel extractive industry employment. Using case studies, we evaluate the experiences of diverse efforts to systematically strengthen regional innovation systems, with a focus on clean energy and manufacturing. In each case, we look for evidence of five entrepreneurial competencies, and characterize the number and criticality of the gaps in these competencies. We then examine the ways that each case intervention has addressed these gaps. We find that interventions that address critical, but not necessarily more, gaps are effective. Buy-in from multiple stakeholders who share an interest in sustaining an intervention, and building on existing local capabilities are also antecedents of success.

For Associates Only

As a benefit to our Associates, the latest Working Papers are embargoed for a period of up to six months before becoming accessible to the public. If you are interested in becoming an Associate or learning more about the benefits of sponsorship, please click here, or email us at

If you are a CEEPR Associate or CEEPR staff member, please visit the login page here: